Skip to content

CALL 02 9723 8080

1300 287 911
JB Logo jb solicitors family lawyer
  • 1300287911
  • About Us
    • Why Choose Us?
    • Our Team
    • Our Fixed Fees
  • Family Lawyers Sydney
    • Divorce Lawyers Sydney
    • Parenting Orders: Parent & Children Matters
    • Mediation Lawyers: Mediation & Arbitration
    • Property Settlement Lawyers
    • Domestic Violence Lawyer
    • Binding Financial Agreement Lawyer
    • Will and Estate Lawyers
  • Other Services
    • Conveyancing Lawyer
    • Sydney Business Lawyers
    • Civil Litigation Lawyer
    • Criminal Lawyers & Traffic Lawyers
    • Environment Lawyer: Land & Environmental Law
    • Employment Law
    • Immigration Lawyer
  • Resources
    • Blogs
    • Events
    • Videos
    • Crimes Act 1900 (NSW)
    • Family Law Act 1975
    • Migration Act 1958
    • Fact Sheet
  • Contact
  • About Us
    • Why Choose Us?
    • Our Team
    • Our Fixed Fees
  • Family Lawyers Sydney
    • Divorce Lawyers Sydney
    • Parenting Orders: Parent & Children Matters
    • Mediation Lawyers: Mediation & Arbitration
    • Property Settlement Lawyers
    • Domestic Violence Lawyer
    • Binding Financial Agreement Lawyer
    • Will and Estate Lawyers
  • Other Services
    • Conveyancing Lawyer
    • Sydney Business Lawyers
    • Civil Litigation Lawyer
    • Criminal Lawyers & Traffic Lawyers
    • Environment Lawyer: Land & Environmental Law
    • Employment Law
    • Immigration Lawyer
  • Resources
    • Blogs
    • Events
    • Videos
    • Crimes Act 1900 (NSW)
    • Family Law Act 1975
    • Migration Act 1958
    • Fact Sheet
  • Contact
JB Logo jb solicitors family lawyer
  • 1300287911
  • About Us
    • Why Choose Us?
    • Our Team
    • Our Fixed Fees
  • Family Lawyers Sydney
    • Divorce Lawyers Sydney
    • Parenting Orders: Parent & Children Matters
    • Mediation Lawyers: Mediation & Arbitration
    • Property Settlement Lawyers
    • Domestic Violence Lawyer
    • Binding Financial Agreement Lawyer
    • Will and Estate Lawyers
  • Other Services
    • Conveyancing Lawyer
    • Sydney Business Lawyers
    • Civil Litigation Lawyer
    • Criminal Lawyers & Traffic Lawyers
    • Environment Lawyer: Land & Environmental Law
    • Employment Law
    • Immigration Lawyer
  • Resources
    • Blogs
    • Events
    • Videos
    • Crimes Act 1900 (NSW)
    • Family Law Act 1975
    • Migration Act 1958
    • Fact Sheet
  • Contact
  • About Us
    • Why Choose Us?
    • Our Team
    • Our Fixed Fees
  • Family Lawyers Sydney
    • Divorce Lawyers Sydney
    • Parenting Orders: Parent & Children Matters
    • Mediation Lawyers: Mediation & Arbitration
    • Property Settlement Lawyers
    • Domestic Violence Lawyer
    • Binding Financial Agreement Lawyer
    • Will and Estate Lawyers
  • Other Services
    • Conveyancing Lawyer
    • Sydney Business Lawyers
    • Civil Litigation Lawyer
    • Criminal Lawyers & Traffic Lawyers
    • Environment Lawyer: Land & Environmental Law
    • Employment Law
    • Immigration Lawyer
  • Resources
    • Blogs
    • Events
    • Videos
    • Crimes Act 1900 (NSW)
    • Family Law Act 1975
    • Migration Act 1958
    • Fact Sheet
  • Contact
1300 287 911

OR CALL 02 9723 8080

Home / Medrick & Medrick [2020] – a Case About Parental Arrangements – The Mother’s Perspective

Medrick & Medrick [2020] – a Case About Parental Arrangements – The Mother’s Perspective

  • Divorce & Family Law
  • John
  • 27 September 21
Facebook Twitter Youtube Instagram Linkedin

Background Information On The Case

This case involves a mother, father and two young children. The mother travelled overseas to attend a family funeral, and the children stayed with the father while she was overseas. Upon the mother’s return, the father locked the mother out of the home and did not permit her to see the children unless supervised by him, with no apparent reason.

Equal Shared Parental Responsibility

The mother commenced proceedings in the Federal Circuit Court Of Australia, where on the footsteps of the Court, the parents agreed to an arrangement whereby each of them would get seven nights a fortnight with the children. Following this, the Court made interim parenting orders by consent, providing that an equal shared parental responsibility arrangement was in the children’s best interests.

Our Thought Process

Both the mother and the Court were concerned about why the father prevented the mother from caring for the children for that period of two months. This revealed a concern in the father’s lack of understanding as to what the best interests of the children were. The evidence, in this case, showed that the mother was the primary caregiver of the kids. As such, by virtue of her position as the primary caregiver of the kids, any significant absence of her presence in the children’s lives would negatively impact their mental health and upbringing, especially given their vulnerable ages. This issue is further exacerbated in this scenario as the father had stipulated he will only allow the mother to care for their children in circumstances he can supervise.

The equal shared parental responsibility arrangement continued until this matter was re-heard, and the mother sought a greater degree of parental responsibility

Reasoning For The Decision

The paramount considerations in this matter were the children’s best interests, as reflected in s60CA of the Family Law Act (1975).

The case considers the factors set out in Goode v Goode [2006], which involved the children’s best interests, highlighted in section 66C of the Family Law Act (1975).

The two primary considerations in the matter are highlighted below.

Subsection (2a): the benefit to the child of having a meaningful relationship with both of the child’s parents: a primary consideration

The father sought for the status-quo to be maintained, which means that he wanted the equal shared parental responsibility arrangements to remain in place.  However, the Court and both parents understood that communication between the parents is poor. The Court does not like equal shared parental responsibility arrangements based on seven nights per fortnight each in such situations. This is because for such arrangements to be practical, both parents must be willing to facilitate an ongoing relationship with one another for the sake of their children, which was not the case.

The mother provided evidence the father both berated and threatened her in front of the children on multiple occasions. He also spoke about her in a despicable manner in the children’s presence. It was alleged that the father also intimidated and harassed her, and evidence showed the father had a criminal history similar to what was alleged.

A family consultant had expressed that the current equal shared parental responsibility arrangement would have a detrimental developmental impact on the children. This was also exacerbated by either parent exposing them to conflict. In line with this, the father’s belittling of the mother in the children’s presence was a significant contributor. The mother had also alleged that the children experienced anxiety during changeovers when leaving her presence. The Court acknowledged this and expressed concern that the equal time arrangement would expose the children to significant conflict. This may then lead to the children experiencing emotional harm and negatively affect their ability to have a meaningful relationship with either parent, particularly the mother.

Subsection (2b): the need to protect the child from physical or psychological harm from being subjected to, or exposed to, abuse, neglect or family violence.

The mother alleged that throughout her relationship with the father, she had witnessed the father use cocaine which made him display jealously, anxiety and paranoia. She also alleged that the father was violent and aggressive towards her, which was heightened by the cocaine use. It was found that the father had previously used cocaine; however, he no longer does, according to drug tests supplied at the time.

In return, the father alleged that the mother’s mental health condition was parlous. Upon evaluation by a clinical psychologist, it was revealed that the mother had been diagnosed with mixed anxiety and depressed mood disorder. This was, however, understandable considering the stressors of divorce, legal proceedings and the separation from her children. She was deemed not to be of any risk to herself or others and capable of caring for her children.

The mother’s mental health was not of significant concern to the Court as long as she continually engaged with a qualified therapist or counsellor.

The Decision

The Court found that primary care should be awarded to the mother and that the father should spend ‘substantial or significant time’ with the children, which was considered five nights a fortnight in this context.

The primary reasoning for the decision was for the children to continue having a meaningful relationship with their mother.

If you are interested in reading more about this case, you can find a full account of it here.

Importance of Seeking Legal Advice

When discussing parenting arrangements in Australia, it is crucial that you seek out an experienced family lawyer to aid you with your matter.

Here at JB Solicitors, we’ll make the process as pain-free as possible. We have fixed-fee pricing for family law, giving you a clear sense of the costs from the start, and we will be sure to help you out every step of the way. With years of experience under our belt, we pride ourselves on making each client’s family law experience as positive as possible.

Contact JB Solicitors today to speak with one of our friendly and experienced family lawyers.

More Articles

Suppose you have any more questions regarding parenting arrangements or any other family law matters. In that case, you should head over to our blog section for more informative articles on a wide range of family law topics.

Alternatively, here are some of our newest articles linked below:

How Are Child Support And School Fees Calculated?

What You Need To Know About Custody Rights For Mothers  

Everything You Need To Know About An Application For Divorce

What Does Equal Shared Parental Responsibility Mean For You?

Our YouTube

For more informative family law content, please check out our YouTube page. Alternatively, here are some educational videos linked below, which are on matters that you may find interesting and helpful

How To Stop Your Spouse From Selling Your Property After A Divorce

Want to Legally Change Your Child’s Last Name? Here’s What You Need To Know

How to Stop Your Former Partner From Relocation Your Child Overseas

澳洲离婚步骤

About the author

John Bui

John has over a decade of experience in family law and commercial litigation which often sees John being called to provide expertise in matters that have an international element involving complex company, trust, partnership and valuation issues. He also advises and appears in matters involving the Hague Convention both at first instance and on appeal.

About the author

William Wang

William is a seasoned litigation lawyer with over 15 years of experience. With his extensive knowledge in litigation across various platforms, including appellant, family litigation, commercial litigation, and judicial review at the migration tribunals and federal courts, William has become a trusted expert in his field.

Get in Touch

Call Us Now

1300 287 911

Related Blogs

Joint Divorce Application Form: A Fairly Easier Option

We see that you want to apply for a joint divorce application form. This means that both you and your ex agreed to have a

Read More →

What Does Child Support Cover NSW?

What does child support cover in NSW? Child support is a type of financial support that a child needs from their parents. These prescribed expenses

Read More →

Post Nuptial Agreement: Protect Your Assets and Finances

Most couples may have probably never heard of pre nuptial agreements in Australia, so they opt for a post nuptial agreement instead. What’s the difference

Read More →

All blogs

Stay Tuned To The Latest JBS News

Upward Arrow jb solicitors
JB Logo jb solicitors family lawyer
WEB PORTAL
Quick LInks
  • Home
  • About
  • Careers
  • For Clients
  • Payments
  • Contact
  • Our Fixed Fees
  • Fact Sheet
  • Events
  • Blog
Family Law
  • Divorce & Separation
  • Parents & Children Matters
  • Mediation & Arbitration
  • Property Settlements & Assets
  • Family Violence AVO's
  • Binding Financial Agreements
  • Wills & Estate Planning
Other Services
  • Conveyancing
  • Commercial Corporate Law
  • Civil Disputes Litigation
  • Criminal Traffic Law
  • Land & Environmental Law
  • Employment Law
  • Immigration Law
CONTACT

Tel: 1300 287 911
Tel: 02 9723 8080

Email: enquiries@jbsolicitors.com.au

Facebook Twitter Youtube Instagram Linkedin
ADDRESS
ADDRESS

Sydney CBD Office:
Suite 1, Level 20, 233 Castlereagh St,
Sydney NSW 2000

Melbourne Office:
The Exchange Tower, Level 1, 530 Little Collins St, Melbourne VIC 3000

Western Sydney Office:
Suite 3, Level 1/203, Canley Vale Rd. NSW 2166

Bondi Junction Office:
103/332-342 Oxford St., Bondi Junction NSW 2022

Languages
  • EN
  • ZH
  • VI
  • EN
  • ZH
  • VI
Quality Policy Statement • Privacy Policy • Terms & Conditions
Copyright © 2025 · Liability Limited By A Scheme Approved Under Professional Standards Legislation
  • Made with
  • by Digital Recipe